Welcome to Papa's Subs & Pizza
At Papa's Subs & Pizza, located in Lillington, NC, we embrace a passion for fresh, flavorful food and exceptional service. Our story is rooted in family values and a commitment to creating delightful dining experiences. Guests rave about our gourmet pizzas, like the Buffalo Chicken and Veggie Supreme, alongside indulgent calzones and the flavorsome eggplant Parm sub. We take pride in offering a diverse menu with turkey and beef alternatives, ensuring everyone can enjoy our offerings. With a warm atmosphere and attentive staff, Papa's is not just a restaurant—it's a community hub where every meal is crafted with care and served with a smile.
-
117 W Cornelius Harnett Blvd, Lillington, NC 27546, United States Hotline: +1 910-814-2500
Welcome to Papa's Subs & Pizza, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of Lillington, North Carolina. Located at 117 W Cornelius Harnett Blvd, this charming eatery has quickly garnered a reputation for its exceptional food and warm service. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or looking for a family-friendly dining experience, Papa's Subs & Pizza effortlessly checks all the boxes.
- Diverse Menu Offerings: Papa's specializes in a delectable assortment of pizzas and subs, alongside mouth-watering calzones and strombolis. Signature items like the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza ($13.99) and Eggplant Parm Sub, crafted 'His' way, highlight the creativity and flavor-packed options available.
- Homemade Goodness: The restaurant prides itself on serving fresh ingredients. Customers rave about the freshness of the food, with no frozen items in sight. A testament to this dedication is their gyros, described by enthusiasts as “to die for.”
- Accommodating Dietary Needs: With a focus on pork-free options, including turkey-based bacon and ham, the menu caters well to diverse tastes and dietary preferences, making it a suitable choice for many.
- Outstanding Customer Service: Owned and operated by a friendly and welcoming family, guests are treated like part of the family. Many patrons have shared their experiences of being greeted with sincere smiles and attentiveness, ensuring that every visit feels special.
- A Hidden Treasure: Though tucked away from the main road, Papa’s is worth seeking out. The inviting atmosphere combined with the aroma of freshly baked goods creates a delightful backdrop for enjoying a meal.
One cannot overlook the rave reviews from satisfied customers. From families enjoying baked wings to couples savoring calzones, the testimonials echo a common sentiment: the food is consistently perfect, and the service is unparalleled. As one patron noted, “The service here truly stands out... everything was served hot and fresh.”
Each dish is prepared with care, ensuring both flavor and presentation uphold the highest standards. Indulging in a Three Cheese Calzone ($11.99) or sharing a Deluxe Pizza ($12.99) with friends and family is sure to leave everyone satisfied. Plus, don't miss out on the famous cheese bread, which many have dubbed “incredibly cheesy and baked to perfection.”
In summary, if you find yourself in Lillington, don’t skip the chance to visit Papa's Subs & Pizza. Discover for yourself why this hidden gem is delighting taste buds with its passionate approach to food and service. Whether you're a local or just passing through, your meal here will surely be an experience to remember!
For orders and inquiries, you can reach them at +1 910-814-2500 and prepare to be treated like family while enjoying some of the best subs and pizza in town.
My family and I have had the absolute best service from this family. Every time I come in I am greeted with smiles and happiness. All of the food that we have received has been nothing but perfect evertime. I highly recommend the baked wings, the flavor is like nothing else that you'll get from any other place around. My kids love the garlic knots, and I prefer the eggplant Parm sub, made 'His' way. But getting the chicken Parm 'Her' way is on another level. The pizza is loved by everyone, 7 family. Also as mentioned in another review, they do not use pork products, so bacon and ham are turkey based, and pepperoni and sausage are beef based. Order and enjoy, you will not be disappointed.
The woman who owns the restaurant is super kind and makes you feel welcome every time you enter. The Gyros at this restaurant are to die for and always hit the spot the food is fresh and never frozen. Definitely a place to come visit at an affordable price !
If you're looking for an exceptional pizza experience, look no further than this hidden gem of a restaurant. The atmosphere is inviting and warm, making it a perfect spot to enjoy a meal. I highly recommend trying the calzone — a delightful stuffed bread that perfectly balances flavor and texture. The traditional pizza is outstanding as well, with a thin, crispy crust that holds generous toppings and rich, gooey cheese. Don’t forget to indulge in the cheese bread, which is incredibly cheesy and baked to perfection. The service here truly stands out. The staff is not only quick to attend to your needs but also incredibly friendly, making you feel right at home. When the food arrives, you can tell it’s made with care — everything was served hot and fresh. One thing to note is that the restaurant is tucked away from the main road, making it a bit of a hidden treasure. It’s essential for us as reviewers to help spread the word about this wonderful place so others can enjoy the phenomenal offerings here. Trust me, it's worth the search for an unforgettable pizza experience!
I had the sweetest experience grabbing a plain cheesesteak and fries (with their cucumber dipping sauce - you have to try it) from Papa's just a couple of hours ago that I felt obliged to leave a complimentary review. I spoke with the owner's daughter (who also prepared my food) and she was so kind to me. I've already had their cheesesteak a few times so no need to leave a review about that as I'm obviously coming back repeatedly (it's delicious!)… the customer service and just pure kindness from this young lady was a refreshing experience after a long work week. It's the kind of thing that *should* happen often in food service (or any service industry) regularly, but does not anymore. With that said, it was still above and beyond. I will be back soon to support this business. Thank you so much for your service and sweet manners.
We were happy to find this hidden gem next to the Foodlion. We placed our orders and the food was made to order (hold the jalapeño). Excellent, quick service, very friendly!
Omg I got tons of food you must stop and eat here. Small little place service couldn't be any faster or better. Thanks for. Great lunch!!! Update still perfect... don't miss this hidden gem if your near.
Food was amazing, the service was even better. Everyone was so friendly and I didn’t wait long for my food 10/10 will be back again.
This place is a hidden gem. If you're looking for pork free pizza and subs this is your go to place. The italian sub all the way is one of my favorites. Lastly the staff friendless is warm and welcoming.